Skip to main content

Cultural Oddity: When Chinese Buddhists Leave Indian Culture Behind

Did you know Buddhism came from India instead of China? Notice the names in Buddhism such as Avalokitesvara, Samantabhadra, Ksitigarbha, and Manjushri, and the founder's name is Siddhartha Gautama. Those are obviously very Indian names, aren't they? Yet, it seems that Buddhism has left Indian culture behind in India. In Hinduism, Gautama Buddha is considered one of Vishnu's ten avatars. A TV series known as Buddha by ZEE TV was created. The cast met with the 14th Dalai Lama, Gyalwa Rinpoche, who is often nicknamed the Buddhist Pope. The TV series was also dubbed in Mandarin. Yet, what amazes me is that Buddhists tend to abandon Indian culture behind. 

The very evidence can be seen in how Buddhist temples are designed by Chinese Buddhists. Rather than designing them like Hindu temples--they're designed to look like Taoist temples. I find it not surprising how many Taoist temples in Cebu are mistakenly labeled as Buddhist temples. Some tend to think that Buddhism and Taoism are the same. However, historical data reveals that the two are distinct even if the two tend to be inclusive. The goddess Guan Yin Ma (Kuan Im Ma in Hokkien) is revered by Taoists as well. The origins of the goddess can be rather vague. There's a Hindu god known as Avalokitesvara. Avalokitesvara is seldom portrayed as a man. Some say Guan Yin is really a man who magically becomes a woman. A similar situation can be found in Hinduism. Vishnu also could become a woman known as Mohini. However, Hinduism has a goddess of infinite compassion known as Gayatri. I interviewed some Indians and they said Gayatri means "she who hears the sorrows of the world". Gayatri is a Hindu goddess often portrayed with five faces and multiple arms. Gayatri is also referred to in Hinduism as the goddess of mercy--a function occupied by Mother Guan Yin herself. 

Several Hindu gods have been transported aside from Mother Gayatri. Brahma got the name of the Four-Faced Buddha. Saraswati was named Bai Caitian by the Chinese. Ganesha is referred to as Feituoshen. Multiple-armed and multiple-headed deities are present in Buddhism. An image of Avalokitesvara (in both male and female forms) can be found with 11 heads and a thousand arms. Samantabhadra is often portrayed with several arms or at times, several heads. In fact, some of the waitresses in an Indian restaurant asked, "Isn't that a Hindu temple" or "Isn't that a Hindu god?" It was when I presented an image of Mother Guan Yin with several arms. 

Yet, the culture of India was left behind. A simple trip to a Buddhist temple would tell you how Indian culture seems left behind. Take the Fo Guang Shan Chu Un Temple (in Cebu City), Phu Shian (Samantabhadra) Temple, and Fo Guang Shan Mabuhay Temple. The structure is based on Chinese architecture. They're serving vegetarian sattvic food. However, the food served is Chinese. I did conduct a bit of a survey about Indian culture. It's amazing how some older Buddhists didn't even know Gautama Buddha was Indian or even Buddha's real name, Siddharta Gautama. Some of the older Buddhists even think Indian food is gross. Talk about following the teachings of an Indian sage while disrespecting the food of the founder. We do have Buddhist monks and nuns eating at Little India Healthy Cuisine in both Quezon City and Cebu City. 

Some aspects of early Buddhist legends have been given Chinese versions. An example is where Guan Yin also said to be Princess Miaoshan, a Chinese princess in the Tang Dynasty. Some legends have it that Guan Yin was a beautiful Indian princess who became a Buddhist nun. Guan Yin's story would somehow be parallel to that of Gautama. Guan Yin gave her eyes and arms to cure the father who disowned her. Guan Yin's selfless sacrifice granted her a similar form to the Hindu goddess Gayatri. Guan Yin soon had a thousand arms and a thousand eyes so she could help countless sentient beings.  

I could imagine a Buddhist pilgrimage to India. This could be very awkward for older Chinese practicing Buddhism. Some older Chinese only eat Chinese food. It would be very awkward if Chinese Buddhists go to India and end up ignorant about Indian culture. It would be awkward if one younger Chinese Buddhist had been eating at Indian restaurants. Now, imagine if the pilgrimage starts serving sattvic Indian food. That means vegetarian food without garlic and onion. The next scene is when breakfast is served. Instead of having the traditional fried ladyfingers, they would be served ladyfinger curry as part of the vegetarian thali. The devotees are ready to eat vegetarian food. What caught them off-guard was the "strangeness" of Indian food. It could be a hilarious scene in which the older Buddhist devotees will hand the food to the younger Buddhists. At the end of the pilgrimage, you might imagine the young Buddhists getting fatter while the rest are getting famished. 

What caused Chinese Buddhists to leave Indian culture behind is still a mystery. I wonder how many Chinese Buddhists are even aware that the founder of the Shaolin order was an Indian monk who was called Bodhidharma? Buddhism seminars have been talking more and more about Gautama's life in India. Yet, Chinese vegetarian food was still served in the seminar instead of learning to cook Indian vegetarian food as well. 

Popular posts from this blog

BRUTAL Truth: Stop HOPING for Another "PNoy-Like President" Because the Parliamentary System will Produce MUCH BETTER Leaders

Let me get this straight, I'm not here to totally dismiss the good that the late Benigno Simeon "Ninoy" C. Aquino III did. I'll try to be least biased  when I'm writing this to "give a shock" to those who tend to treat his term as a "magical time". However, I'm going to have to warn people about the problem of looking for "another Messiah leader". Yesterday was the would've been 66th birthday of Noynoy if he were alive. One can talk good about Noynoy's legacy. However, we need to realize that relying on Noynoy's term is a violation of the Mahathir Mohamad principle of "Never stop learning."  We need to think that there's only one Noynoy and when he died, he died . TV-5 reveals that Rep. Edgar Erice, a long-time friend of the late leader, also said the following: Caloocan City 2nd District Rep. Edgar Erice made the remark in a social media post marking Aquino’s 66th birth anniversary.  In the post, he co...

The 1986 Snap Elections Would Also Disprove the Myth of the "Marcos Parliament"

Anti-charter change proponents love to use Ferdinand E. Marcos Sr. among their reasons, to defend their stand. The argument is that "charter change must be evil" because Marcos used it--a fallacy of Guilt by Association . Please, even Atty. Maria Leonor Gerona-Robredo's supporter  Andrew James Masigan  supports charter change! Now, we must look at Marcos and remember another significant event. It's the 1986 snap elections and why it's also proof that we never had a parliamentary form of government. February 7, 1986, was when Marcos declared snap elections. Two years before the snap election, Marcos even declared that the Philippines was never a parliamentary government under him : The adoption of certain aspects of a parliamentary system in the amended Constitution does not alter its essentially presidential character . Article VII on the Presidency starts with this provision:  ‘the President shall be the Head of State and Chief Executive of the Republic of the Ph...

Facts vs. Gossip: The "Chona Mae" Incident is Proof You NEED to Verify What You Hear

It was in 2012 when the Chona Mae incident happened. I remember the panic when people were running the opposite direction while I was working at Downtown, Cebu. The traffic was bad. People were panikcing. But the real twist? It was actually a father looking for his daughter, whose identity we may never know.  The Cebu Daily News   said this last 2022, which was before entering the post-COVID world: CEBU CITY, Philippines — It has been a decade since the famous “Chona Mae” line was uttered by a father looking for her daughter after a 6.9 magnitude earthquake struck the island of Cebu, February 6, 2012 .  From what was a simple call of a father to his daughter turned out to be the biggest tsunami scare in Cebu City.  “Ang tubig naa na sa Colon!” ("The Water is already in Colon!") was the line that has gotten everyone running on the street of Cebu looking for shelters up in the mountain parts of Cebu.  Today, we remember that frightful yet somehow funny day that w...

Learning About Chinese Dialects

As I look back on my college days, I recall learning more about Chinese history in a Chinese Language Class elective. Yes, it was going back to Grade 1 Chinese, but doing Grade 1 Chinese right. I looked at this video and thought of China's many dialects. A dialect is defined by the Oxford dictionary as, "a particular form of a language which is peculiar to a specific region or social group." The subject was taught in English, not requiring students to learn Hokkien first, and it was how the Chinese school system should've been. Most Chinese Filipinos (like myself) are Hokkien speakers. Amoy is known as Xiamen today, a coastal city of the Fujian Province. I was shocked to learn there are many different types of Chinese, such as Cantonese (used in Hong Kong), and I wasn't shocked to learn that Hainan and Hakka are other dialects in China. Similar to Filipino, China has several languages too! In the Philippines, we have Tagalog, Cebuano, Kapampangan, Waray, and Hilig...

The Anthem of Mt. Alishan's Mysterious Origins

There are many versions of the song "Gāo Shān Qīng" (高山青) which literally means "High Green Mountain". The Taiwan Panorama website also shares this detail of the anthem of Mt. Alishan : Though the Tsou don't actually live within the Alishan Forest Recreation Area, the CFDO had little choice but to build a cultural scene for Alishan on the basis of the old song Gao Shan Qing to satisfy visitors' imagined expectations of Alishan . The Tsou folk singing and dancing had stopped during the recent tourism downturn, but the Alishan National Scenic Area Administration held tryouts in 2008, for which the winning troupe won the opportunity to perform at the Alishan Forest Recreation Area entrance. "Tall green mountains, deep blue waters; the girls of Alishan are lovely as the waters; the men of Alishan are strong as the mountains...": Gao Shan Qing has pretty much become the anthem of Alishan. Gao Shan Qing was the theme song for the 1950 film Happenings in ...