A history blog by a business administration graduate, set to talk about news, current events, historical records, fake news, etc. Just written as a hobby blog since the writer himself is no historian but it doesn't mean he can't be right where some history majors are wrong.
The MV Doña Paz Incident Last December 20, 1987, Proves Bad Systems DO KILL PEOPLE
Get link
Facebook
X
Pinterest
Email
Other Apps
-
December 20, 1987, would be a fateful date. Disasters happen any time of the year and that includes Christmas. Christmas tragedies are as real as tragedies in any time of the year. This would also include a critique against unscrupulous business practices. It's a trend where people go home for the holidays, right?Sadly, a lot of vehicular accidents happen worse on December because of disregarding safety rules than because it's December. Some Christmas season disasters could've been avoided if safety protocols weren't ignored. It's easy to get too excited for Christmas that people don't play it safe. Some people even prioritize Christmas over safety even during natural disasters.
It was in the late 1990s when I heard of Doña Paz. It was dubbed as the Titanic of Asia. It was also in the 1990s when the movie Titanic (which by the way, had fictionalized elements) such as the love story of Jack and Rose. It was that time I became a fan of Celine Dion's singing. It was that theme song "My Heart Will Go On" got popularized. I used to believe that Jack and Rose were real until Google. The Titanic had an estimate of 1,517 deaths. Some of the bodies were never recovered.
However, the Doña Paz beat the Titanic as a disaster. The Safety4Sea website reveals this:
Despite not included in the ship manifest, an estimated total of 4,386 people perished in the disaster and only 26 were rescued, including 24 from Doña Paz and 2 crew members from Vector’s 13-man crew. Most survivors sustained burns from jumping into the flaming waters. None of the crew of Doña Paz survived. Until today, the death toll of 4,386 people remains the largest ever recorded in a single maritime incident in peace time.
It would be easy to blame the crew or the passengers. However, do we ever try to look at the fact that the ship itself was also to blame? As I was reading the Safety4Sea website, I looked at the probable causes. Take note that I'm just writing based on what I read. I'm not an engineer and blog to share the findings of other people with better expertise:
Probable causes
The fatal incident was result of a series of safety malpractices. In 1999, the Supreme Court of the Philippines ruled that it was the owners of Vector who were liable, as the ship was found unseaworthy and operating without a license, a lookout, or a qualified master.
However, the official investigation by Philippine Coast Guard also revealed that none of the Dona Paz crew members were at their posts when the collision occurred, while only one apprentice was monitoring the ship’s bridge at the time. Other officers were either drinking beer or watching TV in the recreation room, while the captain was watching a movie in his cabin. The crew found themselves unable to guide evacuation efforts onboard and this was compounded by the unavailability of life vests that were locked in deck lockers. No distress signal was sent out.
In addition, the magnitude of death toll was attributed to overloading, a common malpractice in the ferry sector. The official passenger manifest of Doña Paz recorded 1,493 passengers and 59 crew members, but amid the Christmas season, it is estimated that the ferry was carrying close to 4,000 people at that night, despite its capacity being for 1,518 passengers.
This would reveal one thing--the series of incidents is caused by faulty systems. Based on what I read, I can come up with this common sense analysis:
A poor system caused Vector, a ship that was unseaworthy and operating without a license, helped aggravate the matters.
There would be a lot of things for the shipping lines to answer for. How in the world was it that the Doña Paz crew members weren't in their posts during that time? Drinking beer, watching TV, watching a movie in the recreation room, watching a movie in the cabin? Sure, these people are liable but does it mean we can blame them alone but not the system? If there were stricter compliances, the chances of such an irresponsible crew wouldn't be that high!
There was a lack of equipment. In short, it was ill-prepared for such a disaster.
Even worse, the ship's capacity was only for 1,518 people in total, including the crew. A lax system allowed it to have 4,000 people. In short, the ship exceeded its capacity. Would the ship have been designed to hold more, having 4,000 people wouldn't be a problem!
What should be interesting is this detail from the extensive research by Safety4Sea:
The aftermath
It becomes apparent that the incident is an unpleasant mix of corruption practices -that allowed illegal purchase of extra tickets onboard amid Christmas season-, poor oversight by authorities -that allowed such corruption practices- inadequate safety culture onboard -that led to the collision- and lack of coordinated response that made SAR operations to start after 8 hours.
Despite being the deadliest shipping incident, the sinking of Doña Paz is only one of a long list of disasters in Philippines’ heavy maritime history. Notably, from 1972 to 1987, when the Doña Paz accident occurred, there were 80 collisions, 177 sinkings and 53 shipboard fires in the country’s waters that resulted in the deaths of more than 4,000 people. What is interesting is that specifically the owner company of Dona Paz was involved in a total of four deadly shipping accidents, resulting in death of about 5,000 people in 11 years:
Dec 1987 – A total of 4,386 die after Dona Paz and an oil tanker collide off Mindoro Island.
Oct 1988 – Dona Marilyn, sister ship of Dona Paz, sinks off Leyte province, killing around 300.
Sept 1998 – Almost 200 die when the ferry ‘Princess of the Orient’, sister ship of Dona Paz and Dona Marilyn, sinks in stormy seas near Cavite and Batangas.
June 2008– Princess of Stars sinks 3 km from Sibuyan Island, killing about 800 people.
Earlier, in 1979, owned by the same company but named “Don Sulpicio”, the ship suffered a major fire that led it to be declared a constructive loss. However, the ship was refurbished and came back to service under the name “Doña Paz”. At the time of the accident, it was already 24 years old. Although the marine inquiry and the court ruling concluded that the Dona Paz owner was not to blame for the tragedy, overall evidence reveals some form of poor safety culture in the company’s history. In 2015, the CPC of the company was suspended. Now, it operates under different name and is limited in cargo services.
We look at this boat by Sulpicio Lines. Why was a ship that suffered from a major fire later refurbished? Wouldn't it be better to already get rid of the boat? If the boat is already too old, why not get rid of it? If we think about it, a 24 year old vessel is an old vessel. Right now, I wonder why the court ruling didn't blame the owner of Doña Paz? I can't be certain since I'm no legal expert either. Anyway, I would like to point out the overall evidence. The overall evidence pointed out to poor safety culture in the company's history. That would bethe bigger culprit--the bad system of the company and not just the ship itself! It's the poor safety culture, which is part of the system of the company!
It's easy to say, "It's common sense that it's not the system but the one running the system that's at fault." Please, a company should be based on systems-based leadership than people-based leadership. What will we do if the manager resigns? The late Jesse Robredo once worked with San Miguel's Magnolia division. What if they all relied too much on Jesse? Jesse became mayor in Naga City in Camarines Sur. If Magnolia relied too much on Jesse--it would've gone down without Jesse managing it! I wouldn't be able to enjoy the delicious ice cream while Jesse was mayor, if San Miguel relied on Jesse! It's easy to blame the negligent crew alone. However, what caused the negligent crew to get into their positions in the first place? Wouldn't it be the lousy system from one after the other, that caused the tragedy to blow up into epic proportions?
Based on the poor safety culture, a series of unfortunate events happened. The poor system led to the loss of Doña Marilyn, the Princess of the Orient, and the Princess of Stars? Sure, there was gap bvetween 1988 to 1998 to 2008. However, that doesn't excuse the poor safety systems. The poor safety culture of the workplace influenced the behavior. The poor safey culture in the Philippines influenced the behavior. All these influenced towards poor safety protocols which leads to disasters! While the authorities are to blame, why not look at the system that authorities have to follow? Despite all these, some people still insist that systems don't matter, just the people running the system!
What was needed was a structural change. It should be interesting that 1987 was also the time when the outdated constitition of the Philippines was written. Please, it's already 2024 meaning that the current constitution badly needs updates or even a total revision in the major areas! However, people still go by what I dub as the Monsodian Dialectic (read here). Blaming people alone will not help. What allowed people to rise up in the first place? For those complaining about Senator Robinhood C. Padilla, just ask why he got there in the first place. The presidential system is based on popularity-driven elections than party-based elections. Why complain about celebrities and athletes becoming lawmers when you support a system that's based on popularity? How do they intend to educate everyone to vote wisely? Social media trolling? Please, I've seen those attempts on Facebook and has it done a thing?
I don't think Doña Paz would've even sailed if there was a better system. A good safety culture would've already dumped the old vessel. Maybe, Doña Paz would've been built from scratch. Maybe, they would've been more careful with who they hire. At the same time, authorities would've probably been more watchful, which may reduce the illegal sales of tickets. The illegal sales of tickets was caused by poor oversight and corruption. A hurriedly written Constitution, further enforcing the lousy Filipino First Policy (and I wonder if its proponents can give me more papers beyond Alejandro Lichauco), etc. would create a domino effect. If there was more delegation of authority between Manila and Cebu (as well as the rest of the Philippines)--I believe that there would've been more easy monitoring against illegal ticket sales. Instead, it happened and the Doña Paz incident was part of the Domino Effect. One event can create a series of unfortunate events. One lousy system can create more lousy systems!
What's so annoying is that some people believe system change is people change. Some people may think the system is, "Well system change is when you put Leni Robredo as president over Bongbong Marcos." However, Atty. Maria Leonor "Leni" Gerona-Robredo and President Ferdinand "Bongbong" R. Marcos Jr. are still under the same system. That means Bongbong and Leni, regardless of who was president, must follow the system. Please, we need to stop believing that the 1987 Consitution of the Philippines is absolute and should never be amended. If so, Article XVII wouldn't even exist! However, the problems such as economic restrictions framed into the constitution make it difficult to adjust for the modern times!
The Doña Paz incident already proves that bad systems have bad consequences. To say there's no bad systems need to look at several incidents around the world, not just the Philippines. Why do you think North Korea is poorer than South Korea? It's because one has a lousy economic system and the other has a good economic system. Why do you think Malaysia is doing better than the Philippines when most Filipinos are genetically identical to Malaysians? It's because of the system. Why do you think Venezuela is poor and the USA is rich? The late Hugo Chavez blamed former president George W. Bush instead of the country's lousy system. Why do you think Vietnam is now doing better than China? It's because Vietnam has a better system than China's curren system.
This incident should be brought back to make people aware. It's not just to bring up the incident but not bring up the root cause. Doña Paz's tragedy was hit by a series of unfortunate events. A country with a mediocre constitution (which was hurriedly written), to the people following a lax system, which in turn makes businesses have the tendency to ignore safety protocols, and it leads to several tragedies. It's not just Doña Paz but also several tragedies before and after it. If there were better systems then I think this incident would've ever been not so severe or would've never happened at all. As always, think that a bad system always causes a series of unfortunate events!
After many years of self-studying the Chiong Sisters Case , I have written several entries on the matter. In fact, I created what I call an "almost-ever-updating" review on Give Up Tomorrow , which was a documentary that challenged my views. I was hesitant to write this review, as it involves another sensitive issue. Some time later, I wrote an entry discussing another aspect of the Chiong Case, specifically the issue of the late Federico "Toto" Natividad Jr. himself . I always thought it was an unethical issue. However, I was able to watch the film on YouTube (via a poor quality upload), and it doesn't seem that anyone from Natividad's estate is interested in fighting for the film's right to be distributed , not especially that Case Unclosed already came out in 2008, now available on GMA-7's official YouTube channel . Kara David did a meticulously good job featuring the Chiong mother, the Uy mother , and even another member of the " Run for Pa...
Several years ago, Case Unclosed featured an episode about the Chiong Sisters, a few years before Give Up Tomorrow came. One of the things I could say is that GMA-7 is far less biased than ABS-CBN in news reporting. The late Antonio "Tony" Calvento even aired a dramatization of Davidson Rusia's testimony , which had Niño Muhlach play as Juan Francisco "Paco" Larranaga . It's easy to say, "Unlike you, I read the Supreme Court decision." This came out a year after the controversial case involving the late Federico "Toto" Natividad and his controversial film Animal had ended in 2007. Apparently, Animal (2004), which was released as Butakal (1999), still remains banned. As I read through the Supreme Court decision , I confess it's a difficult read . Thankfully, I watched Give Up Tomorrow and read the decision. Give Up Tomorrow highlighted several inconsistencies. Should everyone just follow the decision of the SC and ignore Give Up To...
Angat Buhay September 21 can always fill the mind with some thoughts. For Filipinos, it's the commemoration of when the late strongman, Ferdinand E. Marcos Sr., declared martial law , seemingly out of a whim . Martial law is still legal in the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines , provided that it has been studied accordingly by the legislature, whether or not it can be approved. For example, former president Rodrigo R. Duterte declared martial law in Mindanao when the Mautes attacked. Now, the rally against corruption in itself isn't inherently wrong . People need to do some peaceful protests , and it doesn't seem that the people were engaging in degrading behavior . Sometimes, we need to have a peaceful protest to be able to make a difference, as was what the late Martin Luther King Jr. did, to secure black rights , and how female rights activists fought to secure equal rights for men and women, such as Susan B. Anthony . Now, we need to think about how one must loo...
May 5, 1999, was when Cebu City's trial of the decade supposedly ended. There was massive panic when two days after the Chiong sisters, Jacqueline and Marijoy went missing,; a body was found in the ravine of Carcar. Some doubt that the body was really the late Marijoy Jimenea Chiong. In my opinion, the body was hers since nobody has claimed the body. I would like to blog on what I'd call the mistrial of the decade in Cebu City. Although the late Judge Martin Ocampo may be gone, what he did was definitely highlighted in the documentary Give Up Tomorrow . After writing a review of Give Up Tomorrow --I feel the story is far from over as the seven wrongfully tagged suspects continue to remain in the guilty status. It's hard to believe that Francisco Juan Gonzalez Larrañaga aka Paco was innocent. I could remember dropping my jaw, doing some Internet research, and finding the documentary Give Up Tomorrow . The judge himself was described by Mrs. Mimi Larrañaga-Sy...
As today is Rizal Day, I was thinking about how it's easy to mock him for what he did. Some say he should've just left the country and never returned. Some people tell me, "If you want to become a hero, why not get shot?" I always said, "Well, if Rizal didn't get shot then our predecessors will not get their freedom!" The Filipinas Heritage Library shares this information about Rizal: While awaiting trial in 1896, Rizal wrote a manifesto that expressed his disapproval of the armed revolution against Spain . He cleared his name, which he said was being used by some revolutionaries to espouse certain ideals. He said that he has always opposed, fought, and made clear that armed revolution was impossible, absurd, and disastrous. He explained that reforms must “also come from above,” because reforms that “come from below are upheavals both violent and transitory.” He emphasized, however, that like any Filipino, he desired our country’s freedom; and that educ...
This is another fun tribal dance video. I guess my obsession with Taiwanese milk tea (and the tea leaves are grown from Mt. Alishan) got me into this. Also, the tea brand Tealive (which is a Malaysian brand) got me more interested in this video. Using Google translate, the song title "部落情懷" (Bùluò qínghuái) means "Tribal Feelings". It's a good thing to have Google translate these days especially when one is trying to learn the Chinese language.
Today is September 21 and it's often remembered as the dark era of history. It's because the late Ferdinand E. Marcos Sr. declared martial law. Some people demonize martial law without knowing what it means. Even worse, some people who demonize martial law also say that the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines is "the best in the world". What they don't realize is that martial law can be done, when required, such as when former Philippine president, Atty. Rodrigo R. Duterte declared it during the Marawi siege. Also, martial law is part of the provisions of the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines : Section 18 . The President shall be the Commander-in-Chief of all armed forces of the Philippines and whenever it becomes necessary, he may call out such armed forces to prevent or suppress lawless violence, invasion or rebellion. In case of invasion or rebellion, when the public safety requires it, he may, for a period not exceeding sixty days, suspend the privilege of...
While looking for an Aborigine song that gave me an earworm--I found this interesting aboriginal song. By looking at this video, I suspect that this song is actually a love song between a man and a woman,. It does sound very Ifugao-like as well.
Vietnam Times October 10 is mostly associated with Double 10 in Taiwan. However, Communism has its celebration with Hanoi Liberation Day . I got this information from the Vietnam Times on what the day is all about: Along with the victory of Dien Bien Phu campaign, the Geneva Agreements on armistice in Indochina was signed. After many days of struggling in the Geneva Conference, agreements on transfering Hanoi to the Vietnamese people were finally signed on September 30th and October 2nd 1954 in the United Armistice Center Committee. Following the Resolution on September 17th 1954 of the Government Council, the City Troops Committee of Hanoi was established with General Vuong Thua Vu, the commander of the Pioneer Division, as the Chairman and doctor Tran Duy Hung as the Vice Chairman. The City Troops Committee of Hanoi had the task of taking over and managing the city. The Military Commanders ordered the Vietnamese soldier units to take over the city of Hanoi and abide by the policies ...
It's been some time since Miriam Palma Defensor-Santiago died. True, she can be temperamental but she really has a lot of good reasons to be angry. The impeachment of the late Renato Corona was one example. I could remember seething in anger seeing Atty. Vitaliano N. Aguirre II when he covered his ears. Some say she went overboard. Maybe, she did and I think Aguire II didn't deserve to be detained in contrast to instant admonition. I believe that no caucus was needed and making Aguire II get out of the courtroom was more than enough punishment for minor disrespect . She may have clashed with the late Fidel V. Ramos but I can't get enough of her feisty behavior--something I feel the Philippines needs to become a truly disciplined country. Some may say that MDS is very maldita or a very mean woman. I did pass through a teacher who was like her. Sure, I didn't get good grades, she could go overboard, but I'm still thankful to that economics teacher. I'd say I...
Comments
Post a Comment