Skip to main content

The September 21 Luneta Park Protests will DO LITTLE TO NONE to Really Solve Corruption (Under the "Sacred" 1987 Philippine Constitution)

Angat Buhay

September 21 can always fill the mind with some thoughts. For Filipinos, it's the commemoration of when the late strongman, Ferdinand E. Marcos Sr., declared martial law, seemingly out of a whim. Martial law is still legal in the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines, provided that it has been studied accordingly by the legislature, whether or not it can be approved. For example, former president Rodrigo R. Duterte declared martial law in Mindanao when the Mautes attacked. Now, the rally against corruption in itself isn't inherently wrong. People need to do some peaceful protests, and it doesn't seem that the people were engaging in degrading behavior. Sometimes, we need to have a peaceful protest to be able to make a difference, as was what the late Martin Luther King Jr. did, to secure black rights, and how female rights activists fought to secure equal rights for men and women, such as Susan B. Anthony.

Now, we need to think about how one must look at the issue of corruption in the government. People tend to blame corrupt officials alone, without realizing that the bigger problem is within the system. It's gets annoying when I realize that I can talk about corruption all I want, but some of these people (not all) tend to act like the 1987 Philippine Constitution is a "sacred document", then they give sources to defend their claims like Atty. Hilario G. Davide Jr., Atty. Christian Monsod, and the Catholic Bishops' Conference of the Philippines (for Filipino Catholic faithful), which makes me give them a blank stare at their lack of practicality. In the process, they commit the fallacy of cherry picking with or without knowing it!

For example, Facebook pages like Silent No More PH, The Rule of Law Sentinel, La Verite, and We Are Millennials are all good examples of that. I will not focus too much on all their individual fallacies. Instead, I would like to look into their argument that tends to support Davide's views. Davide has often been viewed as defending claims like:

  1. The 1987 Constitution is the only constitution that is a public trust! (Read the refuttal here). 
  2. The 1987 Constitution, despite not being perfect, is the best in the world! (Really laughable given with the results). 
  3. The 1987 Constitution isn't the problem; it's just the people! (Ignores the relationships between people and systems)!
The very idea of trying to fight corruption (the symptom) under the outdated system is like this. Some countries may not replace the constitution all the time, but they have a more flexible pattern that can be done through legislation. One of the major problems in the Philippines is that it focuses on what's called the obsession with short-term solutions. Relying too much on rallies and protests is an overuse of a useful tool, to the point it becomes a blunt knife. A knife is a good tool but overuse can make it blunt. Sooner or later, you will need to discard that knife!

Whether we want to admit it or not, an abundance of corrupt officials are a result of  corruption (or errors) within the system


Sure, the 1987 Constitution has rules against corruption. It doesn't blatantly write that govenrment officials can steal or should steal. However, there are still major problems with the 1987 Philippine Constitution. The 1987 Constitution of the Philippines operates under a presidential system. Before people can bring up the myth of the Marcos parliament--they really need to look into the specifics of how a real parliamentary system works and not just dismiss the argument prematurely!

The 1987 Constitution of the Philippines, running under a presidential system, makes it difficult to hold its president and the government, accountable. What are the reasons why despite the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines' warnings against corruption, that corruption prevails? It's because the accountability mechanism in itself, is a corruption. A corruption within a computer program can destroy the overall flow, or even cause frequent crashes. The same goes for any errors within the "sacred" 1987 Constitution. After all, that's what Article XVII is there for, to give amendments for the future times!

Unlike the parliamentary system, the presidential system doesn't have these features in a parliamentary system:
  1. Having a well-defined government facing off against a well-defined opposition. It's because it's all about party-based politics.The Philippines doesn't have that! If the Philippines had that, the Liberal Party today would be able to scrutinize the Government led by Ferdinand "Bongbong" R. Marcos Jr.! 
  2. Having weekly questioning between the government and the opposition. Those who were complaining about former health secretary Francisco Duque should ask themnselves, "How often was he called to answer for his performance?" 
  3. Weekly televised debates would either make (1) develop a sense of accountability, or (2) refusing to apply thinner on one's face can get one out. A parliamentary system isn't so that even the Devil will become good. Rather, it's all about making sure bad officials will barely enter and they lose their influence, no matter how much they will still have it! Bad politicians will become a black market in a competency-based system! 
As we look into it, those attending the September 21 protests need to ask themselves, "Are my rallies enough? Shouldn't we also protest for constititional reform, to make what we want, even more possible?" 

Most read entries this week

Filipino Baby Boomers Using SMARTPHONES to Write Anti-Constitutional Rants Online

Henry Rose Lee I wrote a blog post discussing Filipino baby boomers using mobile devices , to type anti-FDI rants . Consider this a "part 2" post of my earlier post, even if this blog handles random history rants . It's a strange but true phenomenon that we have Filipino baby boomers writing comments that reflect their fear of constitutional reform. It should be ironic that they have the smartphone and WiFi at hand, presumably gifted by their children. These Filipino baby boomers may be using the devices to stay connected as a co-parenting grandparent (that is, communicating with the grandchildren).  However, if one started reading their comments on Facebook, I would like to point out these things in common, though it's not a monolith: There's still the irritating phrase that I often hear, such as, "When I was your age... I already did this and that...". This is where baby boomers often compare their children (mostly Millennials and Zoomers) to them, ign...

Philosophy 101: Introducing the Monsodian Dialectic

  Some time ago, I wrote about Atty. Hilario Davide is considered a hero by diehard 1987 Constitution apologists . Now, it's time to dig into what I call the Monsodian dialectic. A dialectic is "the art of investigating or discussing the truth of opinions". I'd like to remind people that just because I'm not an economist (which Winnie Monsod is) or I'm no lawyer (like Atty. Christian Monsod), doesn't mean that their mistakes are automatically right, and I can't write where I'm wrong. The stand of the Monsods, maybe even until death do they part, is that there's no need to need to amend the 1987 Constitution. Instead, the usual argument, according to the Monsodian Dialectic, is that we can never blame the charter for the Philippines' ills. If that's the case then how will the Monsodian Dialectic, even answer  Article XVII  which says: Section 1. Any amendment to, or revision of, this Constitution may be proposed by: (1) The Congress, upo...

Rethinking Why Typhoons Are Necessary

I was watching this Tagalog video on YouTube. It made me think about the ecological role of typhoons. The Philippines is prone to typhoons the most, while Indonesia is prone to tsunamis. As I was looking at people who wish storms will never come, they never realize the ecological role that storms play. But first, let's look into the reason why typhoons are common in the Pacific Ocean . THE PACIFIC IS WARMER Sea surface temperatures (°C) around the world on July 14, 2016. Image credit: NOAA/ESRL/PSD Warm sea surface water is the fuel that drives tropical cyclones. If you ignore large-scale anomalies like El Niño and La Niña, the waters in the Pacific Ocean are usually warmer than those of the Atlantic Ocean, and the temperatures stay pretty toasty through almost the entire year . If you were to take a swim in the water off the coast of the northern Philippines, it would feel like you dunked yourself into a freshly drawn bath, just as it would if you took a dip in the ocean at a beac...