Skip to main content

Is an Impeachment Just as Effective as a Vote of No Confidence?

Talks about impeachment against Vice President Sara Duterte-Carpio are on. However, I'd like to show the problem with the impeachment trial. Who can remember when former president Joseph Marcelo Ejercito aka Joseph Estrada was under impeachment trial? One can say that when Estrada resigned,  that proved that it doesn't matter if the country is presidential or parliamentary (since some economic powerhouses are still under the presidential system, like South Korea and Taiwan). However, we need to look at the political aspect of the parliamentary system. Is impeachment just as effective as a vote of no confidence? Let's find out!

What is impeachment?

Impeachment is defined by the Britannica as follows:
Impeachment, in common law, a proceeding instituted by a legislative body to address serious misconduct by a public official. In Great Britain the House of Commons serves as prosecutor and the House of Lords as judge in an impeachment proceeding. In the federal government of the United States, the House of Representatives institutes impeachment proceedings by authorizing a formal inquiry by the House Judiciary Committee, which may then recommend articles of impeachment (an impeachment resolution) for a vote by the full House (articles of impeachment may also be introduced in the House without a formal inquiry). If the articles are approved, a trial is held in the Senate, and conviction is obtained by a vote of at least two-thirds of the senators present. In Great Britain conviction on an impeachment has resulted in fine and imprisonment and even in execution, whereas in the United States the penalties extend no further than removal and disqualification from office.

In the presidential system, an impeachment trial is only done when a public official has serious misconduct. In short, you need to wait for so-and-so to commit a crime like stealing public funds. Estrada already showed signs of being inept. However, people needed to wait until Estrada was charged with corruption before he could even be set for an impeachment trial. 

Eve more, this is a real constraint of the impeachment trial in removing erring officials:

In the United States the impeachment process has rarely been employed, largely because it is so cumbersome. It can occupy Congress for a lengthy period of time, fill thousands of pages of testimony, and involve conflicting and troublesome political pressures. Repeated attempts in the U.S. Congress to amend the procedure, however, have been unsuccessful, partly because impeachment is regarded as an integral part of the system of checks and balances in the U.S. government.

That would be the problem with doing impeachment processes. It would mean having a lengthy process. If I were in office, why would I fear being impeached if most politicians find it cumbersome? I could easily manipulate the outcome with money.  

Now, let's discuss the vote of no confidence

A vote of no confidence is defined by the UK Parliament as follows:

A motion of no confidence is a motion moved in the House of Commons expressing lack of confidence in the government or a specific minister.

Having the confidence of the House of Commons has been seen as central to a government's authority to govern in the UK. Traditionally, governments that have lost a confidence vote have either resigned in favour of an alternative administration, or the Prime Minister has requested a dissolution from the Queen, triggering a general election.

What does it take to remove a person to get legally charged? All it takes is a lack of confidence. For example, Mrs. Carpio's confidential funds are questioned. In the parliamentary system, Mrs. Carpio can lose the confidence of the parliament. Let's just say that the government is ran by Uniteam and the opposition is run by the Liberal Party. The Liberal Party can call for a vote of no confidence, should Mrs. Carpio, as deputy prime minister, refuse to reveal her confidential funds. 

Andrew James Masigan, a supporter of Atty. Maria Leonor Gerona-Robredo (and a pro-charter change proponent), also wrote this about impeachment and a vote of no confidence:

Moreover, since the members of parliament selects the Prime Minister, they can easily remove him through a vote of no-confidence should he fail to fulfill his mandate. We do away with the tedious process of impeachment. And since the ministers are selected from the Parliament, no one gets a free ticket to the Cabinet just because they are friends with the President or nominated by a political ally. The ministers all have mandates and are accountable not only to the PM but to their constituents.

If we look at the vote of no confidence, all it takes for any politician to get into trouble is for parliamentary members to lose their confidence. Things like unwillingness to disclose what needs to be disclosed, are more than enough to call for a vote of no confidence.

Whether we want to admit it or not, systems do shape behavior

It's easy to say things like Filipinos have always been like that, blah blah blah. I'm sorry to say but the problem isn't the Filipino but the system that runs the Filipino. One must explain why there are successful Filipinos in better countries and why there are more failures in the Philippines. It's all about the system. As far as OFW mishaps are concerned, there aren't that much compared to crime in the Philippines. It's because of the system in itself, not because one is Filipino. Please do some research and find out that most Filipinos are descended from Malaysian settlers! Malaysia would still be considered da "huan-a" nation by Hokkien speakers! Huan-a is a word describing natives of Southeast Asia, by ethnic Chinese! Malaysians are considered huan-a too! Why is a nation of full of huan-as doing better than another nation full of huan-as?

I issued a challenge in my post about proving systems don't matter. Please, I don't need a PhD from Ateneo De Manila or the University of the Philippines, to understand systems do matter! What's the use of graduating cum laude from either of these two difficult-to-enter schools, all the while the education system of the Philippines, is questionable? 

To evaluate the problem presidential system is a people-based system. When some people say change the system in the Philippines--they only think of regime change, not constitutional reform. Please, the constitution of the Philippines, is the law of the land, therefore it's the system of the country! To talk about how bad people-based systems are--Titanium Success talks this in the business environment:

If your business requires that kind of a person, you’re always going to be putting too much out there because you’re going to be too people dependent and you do not want to build a people dependent system. You want to build a systems dependent company.

And when you have a systems dependent company and then you put really great people on it and you give them really great training, imagine how good that’s going to be. What it does, it also takes some of the pressure off of your people. Because they are following a system where they know that slight errors aren’t going to cause this entire thing to fall apart.

If the business requires you to wait for a competent person, how long would you wait until this "perfect leader" (there is no such person) arrives? What happens if that competent politician or manager resigns, becomes incapacitated, or dies? The system should depend on molding employees to become the right person rather than waiting for the right person. If the person refuses to conform to the system--the person gets into trouble. Let's use some basic rules for example. Rules like No Smoking, Keep Off the Grass, No Talking During Sessions, etc. would influence behavior. I violate it, I get reprimanded by proper authorities. If those rules didn't exist, proper authorities will have no duty to reprimand me. Why would I smoke if smoking's not allowed in that area? Why would I not smoke if there was no rules against smoking? It's really that simple! 

The same goes for impeachment vs. a vote of no confidence. A public official is free to be an idiot all he or she wants if the only thing that will remove them is impeachment. Impeachment only focuses on officials not doing any acts of graft of corruption. However, rampant graft and corruption is a result of incompetence in people. A vote of no confidence addresses the root cause of corruption. A vote of no confidence is based on the person's competence and not just, "Well, at least he or she isn't corrupt." Sure, a person may not be corrupt in the political sense. That idiot may not be stealing public funds but may end up becoming the unwilling accomplice of the corrupt politician. Allowing incompetence to run rampant becausethe person "isn't corrupt" will allow corrupt politicians (and some do have a shrewd mind) to perpetuate their stay in power. 

In short, the two are radically different. Impeachment only addresses the symptoms. Vote of no confidence identifies the root cause. 

Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

East Asian Culture and Envy Breeding?

I listened to this video and it's not surprising. I thought of the typical problem, "Nobody is competing with you? Why are you always competing with us?" This would have typical competitions like: Comparing the performance of each other's children. Asking someone when one's child will get married. Telling their child so and so has "matured" by getting married (never mind some of the worst quarrels are between married people) and that the other is still "immature". Never mind that the "immature" person may be raising up valid points! Getting angry when somebody prospers, even if it's just a little bit of prosperity. Then again, the person getting jealous may be living a glamorous life fueled by unpaid debt . As I listened to it, I can relate to it because I've been a victim of such practices and also had done such practices. It's a really toxic trait East Asians need to stop.  Let's fact it that no culture is perfect . ...
Read more

Why Using CTTO Isn't a Valid Source at All

Right now, I'm having an argument with a certain old man (wearing a toga, presumably graduating from a doctorate degree) on Facebook. One thing I noticed in some of his Facebook posts is the use of CTTO more often than not. Maybe, I can start giving a sample of his arguments since there are many. One of his posts would go like this: All nations have protectionist policies, its their inherent rights. It is the role of the business to use strategies to work within these policies.... ctto... Back then, I remembered I erroneously used Yahoo as a source in my high school term paper. Later on, a college professor placed an X mark on Yahoo and Google as a source . It's because Google nad Yahoo are search engines . Now, we have CTTO which means Credit To The Owner. If we're to really credit the owner, why not post a link or acknowledge the site where it was taken from? For example, the meme above is by 8LIST.PH.  It's very eays to say CTTO to make myself look smart. However, I ...
Read more

Indigenous Dance in Dayuan District, Taiwan

In the quest to know more about Southeast Asia's indigenous people--Taiwan can become a hit destination. This would look like a group of Filipino indigenous dancers but they're from Taiwan. This long dance number may show how the Taiwanese government may have been treating indigenous tribes better than the Philippines. One article I wrote was about how some Filipino natives now have to travel to Taiwan to learn indigenous weaving .  Just watching this video makes me think of what the  Inquirer  cited about Taiwanese indigenous people: TAIPEI—In communities of the indigenous Amis tribe across Taiwan,  locals say lima for five, pito for seven and mata for eye, just like Filipinos . In southern Taiwan’s Alishan mountain,  the Tsou tribe calls the community’s meeting hut a kuba, strikingly similar in design to the Philippines’ kubo . Whether in language, architecture or way of life, links among indigenous peoples of the Philippines and Taiwan are undeniable, with...
Read more

The Late Lee Kuan Yew Called the Philippines' Press RAMBUNCTIOUS

The Straits Times As April Fool's Day draws near, I intend to write on something the late Lee Kuan Yew said in his book From Third World to First . It was once wrongly said that he said the Philippine presses as masters of intrigue . It was made by a certain Jesus Satorre Jr. who wrongly called Lee Kuan Yew,  president . That alone deserves to be fact-checked . It was even funny how a certain someone called Mahathir Mohamad a president when he criticized former president Rodrigo R. Duterte.  However, there was a quote from the book concerning the Philippines about the Philippine press: Ramos knew well the difficulties of trying to govern with strict American-style separation of powers. The senate had already defeated Mrs. Aquino's proposal to retain the American bases. The Philippines had a rambunctious press but it did not check corruption. Individual press reporters could be bought, as could many judges . I'm afraid that it's very easy to quote what Lee said about the...
Read more

Are People Who Say Systems Don't Matter Be Willing to Prove Their Claims for a Million Pesos?

People often argue that it's not the system but the people who run it. Some people have their examples like the late former Philippine president Benigno Simeon "Noynoy" C. Aquino III and former Philippine vice president Atty. Maria Leonor "Leni" S. Gerona-Robredo. They would say that both Noynoy and Leni are "prime examples" why charter change isn't needed, just a change of people in power. Some people even say that the 1987 Constitution of the Philippines is "inviolate". If that's so then what happened to Article XVII that makes it open to amendments? Why wasn't that even used? That means even making a new constitution isn't illegal per se--unless one did what Ferdinand E. Marcos Sr. did during the martial law era! However, if we understand simple psychological science, we need to look at basic psychology. Please, I don't need a doctorate in certain degrees, in the Greenbelt Universities, to understand that there are mist...
Read more

Scarier Than Any Horror Movie: Two Trials of the 20th Century in the Philippines, Still Case Unsolved

iStock Happy Halloween, right? I would like to write something scary. I've written some blog entries under the label "crime". My two favorite topics are the Vizconde Massacre Case, which was followed by the Chiong Sisters Case. It's amazing that one of the siblings of Marijoy Jimenea Chiong and Jacqueline Jimenea Chiong, was actually my schoolmate at the University of San Carlos. Some people knew this Chiong sibling as Debbie Jane Chiong-Sia, who by the way, isn't Jacqueline . Jacqueline would be in her 50s would she have lived. I didn't care anymore about the case until someone told me, "Do you remember Paco Larrañaga? He was innocent!" It scared me straight. The question was given to me after someone also mentioned Hubert Jeffry P. Webb as innocent regarding the Vizconde Massacre case. I believed that both Paco and Jeffry were guilty. The scary truth was that they were innocent  of the crimes. I got interested in digging into the crimes.  Back in t...
Read more

The Bataan Death March

April 9 (tomorrow) is a holiday but it's a commemoration of a loss during the Second World War. The Second World War brought about a cheerless Christmas than Odette ever did. It's been some time since I studied history and this blog is just a random history blog. I would like to give my reaction to the brutal Bataan Death March. This was when Japan used to be the Empire of Japan, an enemy of the Philippines, all before Modern Japan. The Japanese Empire deserved to crumble after its atrocities. Today, the Philippines is allied with the former AXIS forces of Germany, Japan, and Italy.  I searched on The History Channel to find some information on the Fall of Bataan . The details can be very gruesome. The very description of how the tragedy started isn't very pretty. The surrendered Filipinos and Americans soon were rounded up by the Japanese in April 1942 and forced to march some 65 miles from Mariveles, on the southern end of the Bataan Peninsula, to San Fernando. The men we...
Read more

The Vizconde Massacre and Trial by "Trust Me Bro"?

As Christmas approaches, another case worth revisiting for history vs. gossip is the Vizconde Massacre. I watched Crime Investigation Asia uploaded on YouTube. I wrote about the documentary Give Up Tomorrow -- a documentary that explores the irregularities while pursuing justice for the late Chiong sisters, Jacqueline Jimenea Chiong and Marijoy Jimenea Chiong. I feel compelled to write about the Vizconde Massacre. For more than 10 years, I used to believe that Hubert Jeffry Pagaspas Webb, son of Freddie Webb, was guilty. It turns out that according to Crime Investigation Asia --it was really a trial by gossip . In my case, I want to call it a trial of Trust Me Bro.  I still read comments about how footage of Hubert in the States could've been "easily tampered". Yet, those who comment haven't presented the evidence. I guess if I asked for their evidence, they'll just say, "Trust me bro!" Granted, photo editing was still in its infancy back then so how cou...
Read more

A Certain MARITES Vandalized Wikipedia to "Prove" that the Chiong Sisters Are "Still Alive"

Christmas can bring me some memories. One of them was having a Christmas vacation with the Chiong Sisters Case in mind back in high school. Above is a vandalism I found on Wikipedia (which I take with a grain of salt). Please be reminded Wikipedia is where anyone can edit therefore it's a spurious source. Without her permission, the 2023 photo was most likely taken from Mrs. Thelma Jimenea-Chiong's Facebook. I agree with Marty Syjuco that Mrs. Chiong was the victim of the crime. However, seven innocent people were wrongly tagged as the public demanded answers. There can only be justice for either side once the real culprits are discovered. Some cases happen and the real perpetrators have not yet been found.  I'd like to really point out some simple facts. Let me remind people of the following facts: Amelie Arquilliano-Chiong was born as Amelie R. Arquilliano. She is the wife of the late Marijoy Jimenea Chiong's brother Bruce. She's in Canada.  The three Chiong siste...
Read more